Loading
Speak to an autograph expert now: 816-868-2310 Contact Us Online

5 Things That Affect an Autographed Baseball's Value

July 27, 2019 2 min read 22 Comments

5 Things That Affect an Autographed Baseball's Value

Almost every day I get asked, "What's my baseball worth?"  That comes down to many factors including who signed it.

For the purpose of this article, I am going to just talk about how the actual baseball itself affects the value.

Here are 5 things to look for.

#1 TYPE OF BALL

 Every autographed baseball of any current player should be on an official Major League Baseball.  With the exception of All Star and World Series logo baseballs, the official MLB baseball is what everyone wants.

Official Major League Baseball

Getting an autograph on an Official League ball or a plastic China baseball is practically worthless.

When possible, always go with the official MLB ball.

#2 COLOR OF PEN

Always get a baseball autographed in a blue ball point pen.  Blue lasts longer and is much bolder of a color.  

Mike Trout Autographed Baseball

Black tends to fade very quickly.

Same thing with a sharpie.  Never get a baseball autographed with a sharpie.

#3 SMUDGES OR FADING OF SIGNATURE

No one wants to see a smudge or a faded signature.  Everyone wants a clean and bold signature.  The better the signature, the more desirable.  Authentication companies have even started grading the signature itself along with the autograph.

Hank Aaron Autographed Baseball

 

#4 CONDITION OF BASEBALL

With the exception of older autographed baseballs such as Babe Ruth, Ted Williams, and Mickey Mantle, every current players autograph should be on a clean, white baseball.  Or a pearl it is called.

Felix Hernandez Autographed Baseball

Staining or spotting on the ball tends to bring down its value.

In regards to a Babe Ruth signature, yes, those baseballs will all have spotting and staining due to the age of the ball.

#5 AUTHENITCATION

Having your autographed baseball authenticated by JSA, PSA DNA, or Beckett Authentication always adds to the value of your baseball.

If you were to sell it, a buyer would want to see this authentication with your item.

A Babe Ruth autographed baseball for example sells for WAY more authenticated by one of those companies.

BONUS TIP!

One more thing that can add value to your autographed baseball are inscriptions such as when a player adds his MVP year or when he won the World Series MVP.  

JD Martinez Autographed 2018 World Series Baseball

Personalizations like TO JOHN, always devalue the autographed baseball.

 Reason being is a ball with TO JOHN on it is hard to sell to someone named Matt!

 

22 Responses

Lynne Murdoch
Lynne Murdoch

June 22, 2024

I have a game ball…not signed…with Mariano Rivera New York Yankees 1995-2013 stamp (Rawlings). Believe it was from his last game.Is it worth anything?
Thanks

Stephen Thornburg
Stephen Thornburg

July 23, 2023

I have the 2nd grandslam ball that Fernando tatis hit 4/23/1999. It was supposed to go to the hall of fame but went to a personal collection. I ended up with it a few years ago and now I’m interested in the value of the ball. Wondering what it would go for? Any ideas?

Jared
Jared

July 23, 2023

My sister has a ball she got signed at a minor league game with Derek Lowe, Raul Ibanez, and others including Birdie Griffey (Ken Griffey’s wife and Junior’s mom) has anyone seen anything else signed by her.?

Andrew Tarrant
Andrew Tarrant

May 02, 2023

I have a 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers signed ball, although autographs are faded.

Andrew Tarrant
Andrew Tarrant

May 02, 2023

I have a 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers signed ball, although autographs are faded.

jerry hamilton
jerry hamilton

May 02, 2023

I have an autographed signed by Stan Musial,Curt Flood ,Marty Marion,Lue Brock,, Bob Gibson, and was wondering if it was worth getting certified??

Dan Ives
Dan Ives

May 02, 2023

I have a cushioned official league cork center ball, 7000 prep league horsehide cover official weight & size from Davis Sporting Goods located in Tulsa, OK. Signed by Clete Boyer & Ken Boyer at Oertles Dept Store in Tulsa, OK while playing for the St Louis Cardinals. Signed by Warren Spahn at Spahner’s Dept Store in Tulsa, OK while playing for Milwaukee Braves. All signed in blue ink. Signed by Bud Bloomfield while playing for the Tulsa Oilers which was minor league for St Louis Cardinals. The players rented a house catty corner to my grandmother’s house so I got to interact with the different players as a young boy. Does this ball have any value other than great memories for me?

I also have an Official Gillette League – World Series Special still in cases in its original plastic. This is signed by a few names mentioned are: Smokey Burgess-catcher, Dick Radatz-first base, Albie Pearson-outfield to name a few. Does this have any value?

Randle pearson
Randle pearson

October 26, 2022

I have a Mickey mantle signed baseball on a official American ball league baseball with Bobby Brown pres on it how much is it worth

Primitivo Trujillo
Primitivo Trujillo

October 26, 2022

I have a baseball that was signed by Ford C. Frick as well as signitiers by the players. Also a photo of the players
Where can I take it to evaluate it’s value. I live in Albuquerque

Steve Campos
Steve Campos

October 26, 2022

What if it the ball signed by a future hall of famer (sure 1st ballot) is the home run he hit. And he signed it notating the actual number of the home run hit and then his autograph.

Thomas Marcotte
Thomas Marcotte

October 26, 2022

To Jon. Very nice collection you got going. I miss the old days! Collecting is great and never needs to be departed with. With the exception of death of course.
To Tim on the 600th hundred ball. One word. “Provenance”. Proving the ball is authentic by any of the 4 companies will require you to show how the ball went from the bat to you. Very often historic quests get taped. So, if you can get the identity of the fan who gets the ball and how it made it to the next person and then to you through photographs, videos, receipts, etc. will help you to prove your case.
To Jackie. Yes, a Lefty O’Doul signed ball is valuable. In the last 3 months on eBay, one sold for $1,000. And that is not the best you can do. Some auction houses will get you much better prices if the condition of your ball is very good, but they also charge you for the service.
To Vinne. ANYTHING Yankees is worth something. In your case, your “something” is a good amount of money. If the ball is 65 yrs. old, then we’re talking about the 1957 Yankees. A great team with Mickey Mantle, Yogi Berra, Whitey Ford, and many more. They lost to the Atlanta Braves that year but won the World Series the year before and again the year after this ball was signed. So, most of the players on the ball have value, and collectively the value goes up as well.

Tim Reilly
Tim Reilly

July 10, 2022

Hi. I am wanting to get a qoute or authentication of a Jim thome autographed 600 th.home run ball that was supposedly his 600th.ball plz.respond

Wayne
Wayne

May 13, 2022

I have a baseball that is signed by a group of players . It is from the 60. Some of the names are. Lary Doby, Jim Hegan, Lee Lopez, Dale Murphy There are about 25 names on it. Just wondering?

.

Jon Buckley
Jon Buckley

October 20, 2021

When I was a kid I would write to players. Ended up with about 50 autographs and some touching letters of response from some widows. I’ll never sell them and I don’t care what their monetary valley is. Dixie Howell’s widow, for example, wrote me back a few times. Dave Dravecky, Brett Butler, Vern Law, Cal Hogue, Paul La Palme, MIke Bielecki, Robin Yount, Claude Osteen, Greg Maddux (when he was with the Cubs), etc…

Jackie McQuaid
Jackie McQuaid

October 20, 2021

I have a baseball signed by Lefty O’Doul sending to get it Authenticated. Is it worth spending?

Vinnie scat
Vinnie scat

July 12, 2021

I purchased a baseball a yankee stadium about 65 years ago sighted buy entire baseball team does it have any value

Shammy S
Shammy S

July 12, 2021

I found it interesting when you said that a blue pen lasts longer and much bolder in color since black tends to fade very quickly. This is something that I will consider once I shop for baseball with vintage autographs. Maybe, it would be best for me to consider the quality of the pen used. I would imagine how buying vintage autographs would help me a lot in my plan to collect vintage items. Thanks! https://wrightcollectibles.com/autographs

Jeffrey Delp
Jeffrey Delp

April 27, 2021

I have the entire SFGiants on a baseball I got them to sign as a boy . Willie May’s, mccovey, Marishell, Perry whole team

Mark butler
Mark butler

April 27, 2021

I have a baseball signed by Mickey mantle it says happy birthday mark on it. How much is it worth??

Thomas Strumolo
Thomas Strumolo

April 27, 2021

Have a sports collection to sell. Can I find out who would be interested in buying it

Thomas Strumolo
Thomas Strumolo

April 27, 2021

Have a sports collection to sell. Can I find out who would be interested in buying it

jeff gibson
jeff gibson

March 24, 2020

I have a Diamond autographed baseball either bought in the souvenier shop on 8/10/95 by H Nomo…the forfieted game..or next game Nomo pitched..do you have any info on ball

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.