UPS Package Pending? The Wild Journey to Find Our UPS Driver

If you’ve ever watched tracking updates go from “Out for Delivery” to… nothing… you know the stress.

This week we had two UPS boxes returning to us from a signing. Tracking showed both were on the truck, and we also use AirTags inside boxes as an extra layer of peace of mind. It helps us confirm a box is moving and gives us a backup way to locate it if something goes sideways.

Well… something went sideways.

The Problem: Only One Box Was Delivered

UPS dropped off our delivery, the driver headed back to the truck, and then took off—totally normal. We started checking in the shipment and realized:

Only one of the two boxes arrived.

And we watched the driver leave. That’s when it became a mission.

We didn’t want the missing box going back to the hub because once it returns to the main facility, anything can happen—delays, re-sorting, and the classic “out for delivery again tomorrow” loop.

So we tried to catch the driver that same day.

Why AirTags Helped… But Not in Real Time

AirTags are amazing—when they’re near iPhones.

If the UPS driver doesn’t have an iPhone, the AirTag will only update when it passes near someone who does. That can mean a ping every 15–30 minutes, sometimes more.

That’s exactly what happened.

We’d get a location ping a few miles away, jump in the car, get there… and he’d be gone. We repeated this several times.

By the evening it was getting close to 6:00 PM and we were about ready to let it ride and accept next-day delivery.

But then I decided to try one last time.

The Last Attempt: Found Him at the Perfect Moment

Around 6:30 PM, the AirTag pinged again in an area he’d been in throughout the day. I drove over, followed the latest updated location, and missed him again by minutes.

Then—finally—on the next pass into the neighborhood, I turned off the main road and saw a UPS truck in front of me.

I pulled ahead, honked, and waved him down like we were stopping a getaway car.

Turns out it was the right driver (we’d talked before). I explained:

“One of our boxes didn’t get delivered. It’s a big one—you can’t miss it. We’ve got an AirTag in it.”

He checked the truck… and there it was.

What Actually Happened: The Old UPS “Helper Sticker” Caused Confusion

Here’s the real reason the box didn’t get delivered:

UPS places small “helper stickers” on packages—little barcode/route labels that help drivers quickly organize without hunting for the full shipping label every time.

But this box was a reused box from a prior shipment, and one of those older stickers was still on it. The sticker showed a completely different address—not our address, not even our state.

So from the driver’s perspective, the box looked like it belonged to a different stop that hadn’t come up yet on his route.

It was never going to come up.

The Fix: Remove Old Stickers When Reusing Boxes

If you reuse UPS boxes, here’s the key takeaway:

✅ Remove old UPS helper stickers (or completely cover them)
✅ Don’t just rely on the new label being correct
✅ If a box has conflicting labels, it can loop “out for delivery → back to hub → out again”

USPS generally doesn’t care the same way, but UPS routing stickers can absolutely create confusion.

Final Result: Box Recovered the Same Day

After nearly three hours of tracking pings, driving around, and playing detective, we recovered the missing box around 6:45 PM.

Did we need to? Technically, it probably would’ve shown up the next day.

But at that point it became a challenge—and honestly, it was weirdly exhilarating.

Final Thoughts

If you’re shipping sports memorabilia, signed items, or anything time-sensitive, small logistics habits matter. AirTags help, but proper label cleanup on reused boxes helps even more.

If you enjoyed this behind-the-scenes story, we’ll keep sharing what really happens in the autograph and shipping world.

Visit: powerssportsmemorabilia.com
Follow: @PowersAutographs